********
03/19/2025
Open
Commercial and Trade - Contract
California
Plaintiffs allege as follows:
1. As used in this Complaint, the word "Plaintiffs" shall refer to Plaintiffs CYNTHIA RAMIREZ AND ELIAS RAMIREZ.
2. Plaintiffs are residents of Alameda County, California.
3. As used in this Complaint, the word "Defendant" shall refer to all Defendants named in this Complaint.
4. Defendant FCA US, LLC. ("Defendant" or "FCA") is a corporation organized and in existence under the laws of the State of Delaware and registered with the California Department of Corporations to conduct business in California. At all times relevant herein, FCA was engaged in the business of designing, manufacturing, constructing, assembling, marketing, distributing, and selling automobiles and other motor vehicles and motor vehicle components in Alameda County, California.
5. Defendant FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM ("FREMONT") is an unknown business entity organized and in existence under the laws of the State of California. At all times relevant herein, FREMONT was engaged in the business of selling automobiles and automobile components, and servicing and repairing automobiles in Alameda County, California.
6. Plaintiffs are ignorant of the true names and capacities of the Defendants sued under the fictitious names DOES 1 to 10. They are sued pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 474. When Plaintiffs become aware of the true names and capacities of the Defendants sued as DOES 1 to 10, Plaintiffs will amend this Complaint to state their true names and capacities.
7. On or about June 5, 2019 , Plaintiffs entered into a warranty contract with Defendant FCA regarding a 2018 Dodge Durango, vehicle identification number 1C4RDJDGXJC (hereafter "Subject Vehicle"), which was manufactured and or distributed by Defendant FCA.
Page 28. The warranty contract contained various warranties, including but not limited to the bumper-bumper warranty, powertrain warranty, emission warranty, etc. A true and correct copy of the warranty contract is attached hereto as Exhibit A. The terms of the express warranty are described in Exhibit A and are incorporated herein. In addition, to these warranties, Defendant FCA also provided Plaintiffs with a California Emission Warranty, which Plaintiffs request Defendant FCA produce as part of its discovery obligations in this case.¹
9. Pursuant to the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act (the "Act") Civil Code sections 1790 , et seq., the Subject Vehicle constitutes "consumer goods" used primarily for family or household purposes, and Plaintiffs have used the vehicle primarily for those purposes. Plaintiffs are "buyers" of consumer goods under the Act. Defendant FCA is a "manufacturer" and/or "distributor" under the Act.
10. Plaintiffs justifiably revoke acceptance of the Subject Vehicle under Civil Code, section 1794 , et seq., by filing this Complaint and/or did so prior to filing the instant Complaint.
11. These causes of action arise out of the warranty obligations of FCA in connection with a motor vehicle for which FCA issued a written warranty.
12. Defects and nonconformities to warranty manifested themselves within the applicable express warranty period, including but not limited to, engine defects, electrical defects; among other defects and non-conformities.
13. Said defects/nonconformities substantially impair the use, value, or safety of the Vehicle.
14. The value of the Vehicle is worthless and/or de minimis.
15. Plaintiffs purchased the Subject Vehicle as manufactured with FCA's defective engine.
16. Plaintiffs are informed, believe, and thereon alleges that FCA knew since prior to Plaintiffs purchasing the Subject Vehicle, that the 2018 Dodge Durango vehicles equipped
Page 3Judge
HON. Keith Fong
Plaintiffs
CYNTHIA RAMIREZ
ELIAS RAMIREZ
Defendants
FCA US, LLC.
FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM
Other Attorneys
Tionna Carvalho
MATTHEW C. WOLF
03/19/2025: Complaint
09/11/2025: Minute Order (Hearing on Demurrer Notice of Demurrer and Demurrer; filed by...)
09/11/2025: Minute Order (Hearing on Motion to Strike Defendants’ Notice of Motion and ...)
10/01/2025: General Order (Court Order Continuing Case Management Conference)
09/24/2025: Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint)
09/24/2025: Notice of Case Management Conference
09/24/2025: Case Management Statement
09/15/2025: Notice of Ruling
09/11/2025: Order re: Hearing on Motion to Strike Defendants’ Notice of Motion and Motion to Strike; filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) + CRS# 846023100214 filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant) on 09/04/2025
09/11/2025: Order re: Hearing on Demurrer Notice of Demurrer and Demurrer; filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) + CRS# 497939580713 filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant) on 06/02/2025
09/04/2025: Reply In Support Of Demurrer
09/04/2025: Reply In Support Of Motion To Strike
09/08/2025: Tentative Ruling (Motion to Strike Defendants’ Notice of Motion and Motion to Strike; filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) + CRS# 846023100214)
09/08/2025: Tentative Ruling (Demurrer Notice of Demurrer and Demurrer; filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) + CRS# 497939580713)
08/29/2025: Opposition PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE
08/29/2025: Opposition PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS DEMURRER
08/07/2025: General Order (Court Order Continuing Case Management Conference)
08/04/2025: Case Management Statement
HearingDescription: Initial Case Management Conference; Dept: HHJ / Department 517
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Initial Case Management Conference scheduled for 10/28/2025 at 02:30 PM in Hayward Hall of Justice at Department 517 Not Held - Continued - Court's Motion was rescheduled to 12/04/2025 02:30 PM; Category: Event
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: General Order (Court Order Continuing Case Management Conference) Entered by: Court; Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Initial Case Management Conference scheduled for 12/04/2025 at 02:30 PM in Hayward Hall of Justice at Department 517; Category: Event
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Proof of Service (not Summons and Complaint) Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff) As to: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Notice of Case Management Conference Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff) As to: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Case Management Statement Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Hearing on Motion to Strike Defendants Notice of Motion and Motion to Strike; filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) + CRS# 846023100214 scheduled for 09/11/2025 at 02:30 PM in Hayward Hall of Justice at Department 517 updated: Result Date to 09/11/2025 Result Type to Held - Motion Granted; Category: Event
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Hearing on Demurrer Notice of Demurrer and Demurrer; filed by FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) + CRS# 497939580713 scheduled for 09/11/2025 at 02:30 PM in Hayward Hall of Justice at Department 517 updated: Result Date to 09/11/2025 Result Type to Held - Motion Granted; Category: Event
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Notice of Ruling Filed by: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Declaration Declaration of Arya Shiirani in Support of Defendants Demurrer to Plaintiffs Complaint Filed by: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Demurrer Filed by: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Proof of Service of Summons Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff) As to: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant) Service Date: 05/01/2025 Service Cost: 54.75 Service Cost Waived: No; Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Case assigned to Hon. Keith Fong in Department 517 Hayward Hall of Justice; Category: Assignment
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Initial Case Management Conference scheduled for 08/19/2025 at 02:30 PM in Hayward Hall of Justice at Department 517; Category: Event
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Notice of Case Assignment Filed by: Clerk; Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Notice of Case Management Conference Filed by: Clerk; Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Civil Case Cover Sheet Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff) As to: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Summons on Complaint Issued and Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff) As to: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read LessDocketMessage: Complaint Filed by: CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (Plaintiff); ELIAS RAMIREZ (Plaintiff) As to: FCA US, LLC. (Defendant); FREMONT CHRYSLER DODGE JEEP RAM (Defendant); Category: Document
[-] Read Less