This case was last updated from San Diego County Superior Courts on 10/04/2025 at 13:18:24 (UTC).

Abawi vs Sharp Memorial Hospital

Case Summary

On 01/05/2024 Abawi filed a Malpractice - Medical Malpractice lawsuit against Sharp Memorial Hospital. This case was filed in San Diego County Superior Courts, Central Courthouse located in California. The Judge overseeing this case is SMYTH, MICHAEL T.. The case status is Open.

 

Case Details

  • Case Number:

    ********

  • Filing Date:

    01/05/2024

  • Case Status:

    Open

  • Case Type:

    Malpractice - Medical Malpractice

  • State:

    California

Complaint

2. Plaintiff Heeran Abawi is the daughter and lawful heir of Ms. Abawi and brings the wrongful death cause of action in her individual capacity.

3. Defendant SHARP MEMORIAL HOSPITAL and DOES 1 through 20 were, at all relevant times, is a corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California, in San Diego County, with a principal place of business in San Diego.

4. Defendant DR. JAMES SINCLAIR is an individual, and natural person, who is above the age of eighteen and resides in San Diego County.

5. Defendant DR. MATTHEW PATRIK HEALY is an individual, and natural person, who is above the age of eighteen and resides in San Diego County.

6. Defendant DR. MORTEZA MIRKARIMI, is an individual, and natural person, who is above the age of eighteen and resides in San Diego County.

4. Plaintiffs are informed and believe and therefore allege that at all times relevant to this Complaint, defendants DOES 1-20 were licensed and unlicensed individuals and/or entities, rendering care and services to Ms. Abawi and whose conduct caused the injuries and damages alleged herein.

5. Plaintiffs are ignorant of the true names and capacities of those Defendants sued herein as DOES 1 through 20, and for that reason have sued such Defendant by such fictitious names. Plaintiffs will seek leave of Court to amend this Complaint to Identify said Defendants when their identities are ascertained.

6. DEFENDANTS were the knowing agents and/or alter egos of one another, and each of their officers, directors and managing agents directed, approved and/or ratified all of the act and omissions of each of the other, and their agents and employees thereby making each of them vicariously liable for the acts and omission of their co- defendants, their agents and employees, as is more fully alleged herein. Moreover, through their managing agents, the DEFENDANTS, and each of them, agreed, approved, authorized, ratified and/or conspired to commit all of the acts and omissions alleged herein.

7. DEFENDANTS, by their acts and omission as alleged, operate pursuant to an agreement, with a common purpose and community of interest, with an equal right of control, and subject to participation in profits and losses, such that they operated a joint enterprise or joint venture, subjecting each of them to liability for the acts and omission of each other.

Page 2

8. PLAINITIFF presented to DEFENDANT SHARP MEMORIAL HOSPITAL (herein referred to as "SHARP MEMORIAL" on April 25, 2022 with complaints of chest pain that had started the day prior, along with shortness of breath. DEFENDANT DR. MATTHEW PATRICK HEALY (herein referred to as "DEFENDANT DR. HEALY") was the assigned emergency room doctor treating Ms. Abawi.

9. Defendants voluntarily and intentionally assumed responsibility for providing care and treatment to Ms. Abawi on April 25, 2022 . During her care and treatment, Ms. Abawi was sent for a CT Scan which showed she had "soft tissue nodules in the left anterior chest wall findings may represent recurrent breast cancer." The radiologist recommended a follow up ultrasound in the CT Scan note. Ms. Abawi was discharged the same day and was never told about the nodules found in her chest wall. DEFENDANT DR. HEALY discharged Ms. Abawi with instructions to follow up with her primary care physician or return if she worsens.

10. A few short days later, Ms. Abawi followed up with her primary care physician, DEFENDANT DR. MORTIZA MIRKARIMI (herein referred to as DEFENDANT DR. MIRKARIMI.) DEFENDANT DR. MIRKARIMI did not inform Ms. Abawi of the nodules found in her chest wall at the Emergency room, nor did he refer her for any additional treatment. Ms. Abawi continued on with her life without the knowledge of the cancer growing inside her chest wall. DEFENDANT DR. MIRKARIMI had access to the medical records, was cc'd on the records of Ms. Abawi, yet never reviewed them which was a breach of the standard of care. His negligence contributed to the lack of treatment and lead to her death.

11. In the following months Ms. Abawi was seeing an oncology/hematologist, DEFENDANT DR. JAMES SINCLAIR (for a separate condition) who also had access to Ms. Abawi's records and evaluated Ms. Abawi regularly. During this time, Ms. Abawi had spots on her chest that, unbeknownst to her, were a direct sign of the cancer growing in her chest wall. Over the following months, DEFENDANT JAMES SINCLAIR continually treated Ms. Abawi without addressing the spots on her chest or reviewing the records indicating she had cancer growing and progressing inside her chest wall.

12. In the months following Ms. Abawi's CT Scan in the emergency room, the Defendants, and all of them, had access to her records yet not one of them informed her of her condition or treated her.

Page 3
3 more pages available for this Complaint.

Judge Details

Judge

SMYTH, MICHAEL T.

 

Party Details

Plaintiffs

Abawi, Heeran

Abawi, Homa

Defendants

Healy, Matthew Patrick

Mirkarimi, Morteza

Sharp Memorial Hospital

Sinclair, James

Healy, Dr Matthew Patrick

Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza

Sinclair MD, James

Sinclair, Dr James

Attorney/Law Firm Details

Plaintiff Attorney

Pena, Vanessa

Defendant Attorneys

Basinger, Susan E

Hudson, Clark R

Haggerty, William C.

Other Attorneys

Mann, Craig T

De Heras, Douglas S

 

Court Documents

Complaint

Complaint filed by Abawi, Homa; Abawi, Heeran.; Transaction Number: 21922895 Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran Plaintiff Abawi, Homa Refers To: Defendant Sinclair MD, James Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital Defendant Sinclair, Dr James Defendant Healy MD, Matthew Patrick Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza

Notice of Ruling

Filed by James Sinclair MD Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

Minute Order SD (JO Signature)

Minute Order

Tentative Rulings

Tentative Ruling Published

Stipulation - Fee Due (to Continue Trial Date and All Associated Dates and Order)

to Continue Trial Date and All Associated Dates and Order Filed by Homa Abawi, Heeran Abawi, Susan Antolin, Dr Matthew Patrick Healy, Dr Morteza Mirkarimi, Sharp Memorial Hospital, Dr James Sinclair, The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc. Filed By: Defendant The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc. Plaintiff Abawi, Homa Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran Plaintiff Antolin, Susan Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza Defendant Healy, Dr Matthew Patrick Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital Defendant Sinclair, Dr James

Notice of Hearing SD

Notice of Hearing

Notice of Hearing SD

Notice of Hearing

Opposition (Notice of Non Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment)

Notice of Non Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment Filed by Homa Abawi, Heeran Abawi, Susan Antolin Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran Plaintiff Antolin, Susan

Notice of Change of Firm Name

Filed by James Sinclair MD Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

Proof of Service (Proof of Service-Shajan)

Proof of Service-Shajan Filed by Homa Abawi, Heeran Abawi, Susan Antolin Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran Plaintiff Antolin, Susan

Answer/Response/Denial (Unlimited)

Filed by Josh Shajan Filed By: Defendant Shajan, Josh, MD

Amendment to Complaint (Doe 2)

Doe 2 Filed by Homa Abawi, Heeran Abawi, Susan Antolin Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran Plaintiff Antolin, Susan Refers To: Defendant Shajan, Josh, MD

Compendium of Exhibits and/or Attachments in Support of a Filing

Filed by James Sinclair MD Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

Compendium of Exhibits and/or Attachments in Support of a Filing

Filed by James Sinclair MD Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

Compendium of Exhibits and/or Attachments in Support of a Filing

Filed by James Sinclair MD Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

Stipulation - Fee Due (Stipulation to Continue Motion for Summary Judgement and Jury Trial)

Stipulation to Continue Motion for Summary Judgement and Jury Trial Filed by Homa Abawi, Heeran Abawi, Susan Antolin Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran Plaintiff Antolin, Susan Refers To: Defendant Sinclair, Dr James Defendant The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc. Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza Defendant Healy, Dr Matthew Patrick

Notice of Jury Fee Deposit (Defendant The Doctors Office & Walk-In Clinic Ca, Inc.'s Notice of Posti

Defendant The Doctors Office & Walk-In Clinic Ca, Inc.'s Notice of Posting Jury Fees Filed by The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc. Filed By: Defendant The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc.

Memorandum of Points and Authorities

Filed by James Sinclair MD Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

64 More Documents Available

 

Docket Entries

05/22/2026

HearingHearing Department: Department: C-67; Hearing Type / Comments: Jury Trial

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
05/08/2026

HearingHearing Department: Department: C-67; Hearing Type / Comments: Trial Readiness Conference

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/23/2026

HearingHearing Department: Department: C-67; Hearing Type / Comments: Summary Judgment/Summary Adjudication

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
12/19/2025

HearingHearing Department: Department: C-67; Hearing Type / Comments: Summary Judgment/Summary Adjudication

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
10/03/2025
View Court Documents

DocketNotice of Ruling; Filed by James Sinclair MD; Filed By: Defendant Sinclair MD, James

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
10/03/2025
View Court Documents

DocketMinute Order

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
10/02/2025
View Court Documents

DocketTentative Ruling Published

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
09/19/2025
View Court Documents

DocketNotice of Hearing

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
09/19/2025
View Court Documents

DocketNotice of Hearing

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
09/12/2025
View Court Documents

DocketStipulation - Fee Due; to Continue Trial Date and All Associated Dates and Order Filed by Homa Abawi, Heeran Abawi, Susan Antolin, Dr Matthew Patrick Healy, Dr Morteza Mirkarimi, Sharp Memorial Hospital, Dr James Sinclair, The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc.; Filed By: Defendant The Doctors Office and Walk-In Clinic CA, Inc.; Plaintiff Abawi, Homa; Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran; Plaintiff Antolin, Susan; Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza; Defendant Healy, Dr Matthew Patrick; Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital; Defendant Sinclair, Dr James

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
63 More Docket Entries
02/13/2024
View Court Documents

DocketAnswer; Answer filed by Sharp Memorial Hospital.; Transaction Number: 21964188; Filed By: Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
02/13/2024
View Court Documents

DocketProof of Service; Proof of Service filed by Sharp Memorial Hospital.; Transaction Number: 21964188; Filed By: Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/08/2024
View Court Documents

DocketCase initiation form printed.

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/08/2024

DocketCivil Case Management Conference scheduled for 08/30/2024 at 10:30:00 AM at Central in C-67 Eddie C Sturgeon.

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/08/2024

DocketSummons issued.

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/05/2024

DocketCase assigned to Judicial Officer Sturgeon, Eddie.

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/05/2024
View Court Documents

DocketCivil Complaint; Complaint filed by Abawi, Homa; Abawi, Heeran.; Transaction Number: 21922895; Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran; Plaintiff Abawi, Homa; Refers To: Defendant Sinclair MD, James; Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital; Defendant Sinclair, Dr James; Defendant Healy MD, Matthew Patrick; Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/05/2024
View Court Documents

DocketSummons (Civil); Original Summons filed by Abawi, Homa.; Transaction Number: 21922895; Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa; Refers To: Defendant Healy MD, Matthew Patrick; Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza; Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital; Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran; Defendant Sinclair, Dr James

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/05/2024
View Court Documents

DocketCivil Case Cover Sheet; Civil Case Cover Sheet filed by Abawi, Homa.; Transaction Number: 21922895; Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa; Refers To: Defendant Healy MD, Matthew Patrick; Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza; Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital; Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran; Defendant Sinclair, Dr James

[+] Read More [-] Read Less
01/05/2024
View Court Documents

DocketDeclaration - Other; Declaration - Other (HEERAN ABAWI PURSUANT TO CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE I 377.32 AND WELFARE & INSTITUTIONS CODE $ 15657.3) filed by Abawi, Homa.; Transaction Number: 21922895; Filed By: Plaintiff Abawi, Homa; Refers To: Plaintiff Abawi, Heeran; Defendant Sharp Memorial Hospital; Defendant Sinclair, Dr James; Defendant Healy MD, Matthew Patrick; Defendant Mirkarimi, Dr Morteza

[+] Read More [-] Read Less

Search Court Records