Fourth Appellate District Court Records

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: OPINION FILED.

DESCRIPTION: CAUSE SUBMITTED.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.; NOTES: CHECK STATUS OF S2898726/10/25: CHECKED SUPREME COURT. STILL PENDING.08/11/2025: CHECKED SUPREME COURT. STILL PENDING.10/1/2025: CHECKED SUPREME COURT. STILL PENDING.

DESCRIPTION: PETITION FOR REVIEW GRANTED IN SUPREME COURT.; NOTES: FILED ON 7/30/25. THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED MATTER WAS GRANTED AND HELD FOR PEOPLE V. RHODIUS (2025) 17 CAL.5TH I 050, WHICH IS NOW FINAL. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS NOW DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. ESPINO (S286987) (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.512(D)(2)), OR PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL BRIEFING PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.520, IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: AFFIRMED/PART, REV/PART, REMANDED W/DIRECTION; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL WE REVERSE THE CONVICTIONS ON COUNTS 5, 6, AND 8. AT RESENTENCING, THE TRIAL COURT IS DIRECTED TO APPLY 15 PERCENT CONDUCT CREDIT TO AYALA'S PRESENTENCE CONFINEMENT CONSISTENT WITH PENAL CODE SECTION 2933.1. WE OTHERWISE AFFIRM.; PUBLICATION STATUS: SIGNED UNPUBLISHED; AUTHOR: CASTILLO, JOSE SCHER; PARTICIPANTS: IRION, JOAN K. (CONCUR) RUBIN, DAVID M. (CONCUR)

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: PETITION FOR REVIEW GRANTED IN SUPREME COURT.; NOTES: FILED ON 7/9/25

DESCRIPTION: SOMETHING IS DUE; SEE NOTE.; NOTES: CHECK STATUS OF S289832. DEFERRED PENDING DISPO OF S286987.

DESCRIPTION: SUPREME COURT ORDER FILED RE:; NOTES: FILED ON 7/30/25. THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED MATTER WAS GRANTED AND HELD FOR PEOPLE V. RHODIUS (2025) 17 CAL.5TH 1050, WHICH IS NOW FINAL. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS NOW DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. ESPINO (S286987) (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.512( D)(2) ), OR PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL BRIEFING PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.520, IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: EXHIBITS RETURNED TO COUNTY CLERK.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: AFFIRMED IN PART AND REVERSED IN PART; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL; PUBLICATION STATUS: SIGNED UNPUBLISHED; AUTHOR: RAPHAEL, MICHAEL J.; PARTICIPANTS: MILLER, DOUGLAS P. (CONCUR) CODRINGTON, CAROL D. (CONCUR)

DESCRIPTION: SOMETHING IS DUE; SEE NOTE.; NOTES: CHECK STATUS OF RELATED CASE S283169.

DESCRIPTION: PETITION FOR REVIEW GRANTED IN SUPREME COURT.; NOTES: FILED ON 7/30/25. THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED MATTER WAS GRANTED AND HELD FOR PEOPLE V. RHODIUS (2025) 17 CAL.5TH 1050, WHICH IS NOW FINAL. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS NOW DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. ESPINO (S286987) (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.512( D)(2)), OR PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL BRIEFING PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.520, IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: AFFIRMED IN FULL; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL WE AFFIRM.; PUBLICATION STATUS: SIGNED UNPUBLISHED; AUTHOR: CASTILLO, JOSE SCHER; PARTICIPANTS: BUCHANAN, MARTIN (CONCUR) O'ROURKE, TERRY B. (CONCUR)

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: SOMETHING IS DUE; SEE NOTE.; NOTES: CHECK STATUS OF S292790.

DESCRIPTION: RECEIVED DOCUMENT ENTITLED:; NOTES: SERVICE COPY OF ANSWER TO PETITION FOR REVIEW BY COUNSEL FOR RESPONDENT.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.; NOTES: PENDING IN SUPREME COURT (S290868)

DESCRIPTION: SUPREME COURT ORDER FILED RE:; NOTES: DTD SEP 17, 2025; THE ABOVE-CAPTIONED MATTER WAS GRANTED AND HELD FOR PEOPLE V. RHODIUS (2025) 17 CAL.5TH 1050, WHICH IS NOW FINAL. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS NOW DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. ESPINO (S286987) (CRC, RULE 8.512(D)(2)), OR PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL BRIEFING PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.520, IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. (S290868)

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: REVERSED & REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT W/DIRECTIONS; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL; PUBLICATION STATUS: SIGNED UNPUBLISHED; AUTHOR: MENETREZ, FRANK J.; PARTICIPANTS: MCKINSTER, ART W. (CONCUR) FIELDS, RICHARD TODD (CONCUR)

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: AFFIRMED IN FULL; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL AFFIRMED. (SANCHEZ) MOTOIKE SCOTT.; PUBLICATION STATUS: SIGNED UNPUBLISHED; AUTHOR: SANCHEZ, MAURICE; PARTICIPANTS: MOTOIKE, JOANNE (CONCUR) SCOTT, NATHAN R. (CONCUR)

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: REVERSED & REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT W/DIRECTIONS; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL; PUBLICATION STATUS: SIGNED UNPUBLISHED; AUTHOR: MCKINSTER, ART W.; PARTICIPANTS: MILLER, DOUGLAS P. (CONCUR) MENETREZ, FRANK J. (CONCUR)

DESCRIPTION: RECEIVED COPY OF SUPREME COURT FILING.; NOTES: DTD AUG 20, 2025; MATTER WAS GRANTED AND HELD FOR PEOPLE V. RHODIUS (2025) 17 CAL.5TH I 050, WHICH IS NOW FINAL. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS NOW DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. ESPINO (S286987) (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.512(D)(2)), OR PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL BRIEFING PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.520, IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. (S289882)CORRIGAN, J ., WAS ABSENT AND DID NOT PARTICIPATE.

DESCRIPTION: PETITION FOR REVIEW GRANTED IN SUPREME COURT.; NOTES: DTD APR 23, 2025 (S289882); THE PETITION FOR REVIEW IS GRANTED. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. RHODIUS, S283169 (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.512(D)(2)), OR PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT. SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL BRIEFING, PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.520, IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER OF THE COURT.

DESCRIPTION: RECORD SHIPPED TO RECORDS CENTER; NOTES: E-FILED

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: ON NOVEMBER CALENDAR.; NOTES: 8:30 A.M.

DESCRIPTION: CALENDAR NOTICE SENT. CALENDAR DATE:; NOTES: NOV 5, 2025 @ 8:30 A.M.

DESCRIPTION: **CALENDAR NOTICE SENT** CALENDAR DATE:; NOTES: THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 2025 AT 1:30 P.M.

DESCRIPTION: FILED:; NOTES: RESPONDENT'S NOTICE OF SUBMITTING HYPERLINKED BRIEFS

DESCRIPTION: RESPONDENT'S BRIEF.

DESCRIPTION: RECEIVED:; NOTES: CERTIFICATE OF COUNTY CLERK RE DEFENSE EXHIBIT A SENT IN PERSON TO THIS COURT.

DESCRIPTION: CASE FULLY BRIEFED.

DESCRIPTION: APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF.; NOTES: PLAINTIFF AND APPELLANT: BILHAH LOPEZ ATTORNEY: JIHAD M SMAILI ONE EXTENSION GRANTED FOR A TOTAL OF 14 DAYS: 06/03/2025 STIPULATION OF EXTENSION OF TIME FILED:. DUE ON 06/23/2025 BY 14 DAY(S)

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: RECORD SHIPPED TO RECORDS CENTER; NOTES: ALL DOCUMENTS SCANNED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: RECORD SHIPPED TO RECORDS CENTER; NOTES: ALL DOCUMENTS SCANNED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.; NOTES: (IN E085028)

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.; NOTES: (IN E085028)

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.; NOTES: PENDING IN SUPREME COURT

DESCRIPTION: PETITION FOR REVIEW GRANTED IN SUPREME COURT.; NOTES: DTD JAN 22, 2025. FURTHER ACTION IN THIS MATTER IS DEFERRED PENDING CONSIDERATION AND DISPOSITION OF A RELATED ISSUE IN PEOPLE V. RHODIUS, S283169 (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 8.512(D)(2)). ADDITIONAL BRIEFING IS DEFERRED PENDING FURTHER ORDER. (S288307)

DESCRIPTION: ON OCTOBER CALENDAR.

DESCRIPTION: CALENDAR NOTICE SENT ELECTRONICALLY. CALENDAR DATE:

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: RECORD SHIPPED TO RECORDS CENTER; NOTES: ALL DOCUMENTS ARE SCANNED.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: CASE BRIEFED AND ON ASSIGNMENT PANEL.

DESCRIPTION: CASE FULLY BRIEFED.

DESCRIPTION: RECEIVED DOCUMENT ENTITLED:; NOTES: BANKRUPTCY ORDER OF DISCHARGE

DESCRIPTION: RECEIVED DOCUMENT ENTITLED:; NOTES: ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO DELAY DISCHARGE

DESCRIPTION: PETITION SUMMARILY DENIED BY ORDER; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL THE PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE AND SUPPLEMENTAL FILINGS HAVE BEEN READ AND CONSIDERED BY JUSTICES HUFFMAN, IRION, AND DATO. PETITIONERS' MOTION TO SEAL EXHIBITS 22 AND 23 IS GRANTED. PETITIONERS HAVE SHOWN THAT MAINTAINING THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF THIS INFORMATION IS AN OVERRIDING INTEREST THAT OVERCOMES THE RIGHT OF PUBLIC ACCESS TO THE DOCUMENTS. (SEE CAL. RULES OF COURT, RULE 2.550(D).) THE PETITION IS DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: RECORD SHIPPED TO RECORDS CENTER; NOTES: LIST # 82 LOC #591337418

DESCRIPTION: SEALED FILE/RECORD SENT TO STORAGE.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF.

DESCRIPTION: ORAL ARGUMENT WAIVER NOTICE SENT.

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.

DESCRIPTION: SOMETHING IS DUE; SEE NOTE.; NOTES: CHECK STATUS OF SUPREME COURT PETITION FOR REVIEW GRANTED ON 6-26-25. MATTER DEFERRED PENDING S283169. 7-16-25 - PER ALEX, MOVE 90 DAYS 7-31-25 - S.C. ORDER, CASE DEFERRED PENDING S286987.

DESCRIPTION: REMITTITUR ISSUED.; NOTES: CHECK STATUS OF S286987.

DESCRIPTION: TRANSFERRED TO COURT OF APPEAL; DISPOSITION TYPE: FINAL DIVISION 1

DESCRIPTION: CASE COMPLETE.

DESCRIPTION: APPELLANT'S OPENING BRIEF.

DESCRIPTION: EMAIL SENT TO:; NOTES: COUNSEL WITH TRANSMISSION OF EXHIBITS FORM

DESCRIPTION: NOTE:

DESCRIPTION: RECORD SHIPPED TO RECORDS CENTER; NOTES: ALL DOCUMENTS SCANNED.